Op-Eds: Homelessness in Salt Lake City and San Francisco - Breaking the Cycle - CycleBlaze

August 2, 2024

Op-Eds: Homelessness in Salt Lake City and San Francisco

2017 Op-Ed published in The Salt Lake Tribune

Op-Ed submitted this afternoon to The San Francisco Chronicle:

The Homeless: Choosing a Way that Works

There is another way.  In fact, there are many other ways that actually work – clearing encampments does not work.  

More homeless people live in California than any other state, and San Francisco is in the top ten cities for homeless population.  There are public health and quality of life problems that come along with high numbers of homeless persons.  Governor Newsome and the state have dedicated resources and tax dollars to addressing the problem, yet, I know we can do better–and in other times and places, we have.  

In Rochester, NY, rather than bulldozing encampments, government and local organizations collaborated to enhance them (see https://13wham.com/news/local/peace-village-improvements-pcho-snow-cold-weather-homeless-unhoused ) .  A few years ago, Germany started supplying sleeping pods for the homeless (see https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsround/55778733 ).  Mitch Snyder and the creation of CCNV in the 1980s saved thousands of  lives in Washington DC, and it still does.  

As of this writing, I’m near the end of a cross-country bike ride to raise awareness and funds to address homelessness.  The funds raised have gone to a dozen local organizations across the country that have effectively, humanely housed the homeless for decades.   

Tuesday, August 13th, two organizations in San Francisco will receive the Breaking the Cycle Award: Hospitality House and Mission Action (previously Dolores Street Community Services).  At that event I will discuss ways to eradicate homelessness in San Francisco and California.  In other districts and nations–where the numbers aren’t as daunting–any one of the following can–and has–proved effective.  

In California, a multipronged strategy that includes some or all of the following is needed: 

1. Add boarding facilities to the high school with the highest percentage of students identified as low socio-economic status;

2. Support religious institutions’ efforts by providing assistance to add 1-2 trailers/mini-homes on their property to serve the homeless; 

3. Expand and enhance rooms for refugees programs to include our homegrown refugees;

4. Partner with vocational programs and NGOs to build mini-homes for the homeless;  

5. Collaborate with local organizations and businesses to convert abandoned/vacant homes, offices, and buildings to apartments for the homeless;

6. Collaborate with local organizations and businesses to convert motels to permanent supportive housing for the homeless;

7. Identify effective local organizations and give them the resources they need to increase their capacity;  

8. Establish a robust homelessness prevention system that enables law enforcement, landlords, philanthropists, local NGOs and the local housing authority to provide rent support to eradicate eviction.

All of the above have been tried and have worked.  Clearing encampments does not work–it’s a waste of time, money, and resources.  It’s a permanent stain on our character.  The encampments quickly reappear.  Prisons cost taxpayers three to five times more than the above eight suggestions.   

Rate this entry's writing Heart 1
Comment on this entry Comment 2
Bill ShaneyfeltAgreed, but by only addressing housing, you are merely picking leaves from the homelessness tree without getting to the root.

They need to be encouraged to get jobs, on how to get jobs, encouraged to stay employed once working, encouraged to quit drugs, encouraged to avoid alcohol and much more getting to the core reasons they are homeless. I know plenty of homeless here in Dayton. Most have behavior or alcohol or drug problems. Others just do not want to be bothered to get up and go to work.

One guy specifically said that he does not want to get a job because then he would lose his benefits. He does odd jobs for cash. Another guy panhandles for the same reason, and then runs to the liquor store when he's got enough for a good drunk. Both of them "live" locally. All the wooded areas along the bike path are encampments. Trash and clothes thrown about. If what they wear gets dirty, they go to a shelter and get handouts and throw their dirty stuff along the bike path. Sad, sad.

Granted, there are legitimate homeless who are just trying to survive, but they are the minority, and eventually break free.
Reply to this comment
3 months ago
Gordon BrownTo Bill ShaneyfeltThanks for the comment Bill. Actually, a) only about 30% of the homeless suffer from substance abuse--and for half of those it's an effect--not a cause; more than 15% of the general population suffer substance abuse; b) I was surprised to discover how many homeless people are actually working and/or have/had successful careers, as professors, teachers, police officers, in the hospitality and construction industries, etc. c) isn't it the saddest cases, i.e. those suffering from addiction, mental illness, or unemployable, that we're supposed to help the most?
Reply to this comment
3 months ago